Here is the updated review of the Islands wings, dated July 2011:
A little over a month ago, I did a review of the best wings on the island. Since then, a few things have changed. For one, the Longwood Brewpub has changed up their game. They’ve finally introduced a spicy wing, which I believe I might have recommended! And – wouldn’t you know it? – Craig Street changed theirs, with dire consequences! So the following changes need to be made to my ratings:
Longwood Brewpub: 5/5!! Once a runner-up to Craig’s because of a lack of spiciness, this baby now makes the best wings on the island! While the jalapeno wings have been around for some time, they possessed just a little kick, not the spicey punch in the gullet I personally crave! But with the addition of the suicide hots, that’s all remedied! Plump, tasty, well-prepared, and now nice and spicey! Best wings on the island!
Canoe Club: 4.5/5 Comparable to the better wings I’ve had on the island as of late, and with the decline of some of my favorite places, the Canoe Club just might become my new go-to wing place! They were plump, juicy, had a good level of spice, and came with a damn good blue cheese sauce. And unlike some other places, the sauce seemed to consist more of just Franks Red Hot. Nothing personal, but if you’re making wings, it seems lazy not to make your own sauce!
Craig Street Brewpub: 3/5… A sad day indeed! Not long ago, my wife and I went back to our favorite watering holes, right up there with Swans and Spinnakers. I was wary, having had wings there that were clearly different once already. But this visit confirmed my worst fears: they’ve changed the wings and not for the better! They took what was an original and turned it into a generic knock-off! Whereas they were trim and tastily glazed with sauce, now they’re thick skinned and slathered in it! And the sauce has changed too, I swear to God its just Franks Red Hot with some added chili flakes! Not impressed Craig’s! You had the best wings and for some reason, you decided to downgrade. And the serving I had last time was dry, overcooked, and oversauced. I choose to believe this was an aberration, which is why I’m only dropping you two grades!
(New mention!) Glo Nightclub: 3.5/5 located on the Gorge, this posh “Euro pub and Grill” does a pretty good spread. Their wings are not stellar, but they get the job done, especially when paired with a spinach salad (never liked the beets though!). The sauce is basic, Frank’s Red Hot, but at least they tell you that up front. And like most of the menu, they’re not cheap, but when you sit down and take in the atmosphere, decent food, many taps and house music playing the background, you’ll know where your money went. Been a few times and plan to go back!